[016] 22 Icons

[digitaldesigner]

[01-01] Arrow
[02-02] The Avengers
[03-03] Iceman
[04-04] Supernatural
[05-05] Brave
[06-06] Mad Men
[07-07] Elementary
[08-08] Castle
[09-09] The Americans
[10-10] Once Upon a Time
[11-11] Restless
[12-12] Chicago Fire
[13-13] Being Human US
[14-14] Being Human UK
[15-15] Star Trek Into Darkness
[16-17] Beauty and the Beast
[18-19] Dollhouse
[20-20] New Girl
[21-21] Star Trek
[22-22] Veronica Mars

Most of these were from a battle that everythingshiny hosted. You can see the rest here.

[01-05] [06-10] [11-15] [16-20] [21-22]

Please credit kalao if you use.
Comments are ♥
If you like what you see, please add me for more updates.

Comments

[digitaldesigner]

Yeah, I feel the same way. I don't get why people vote based solely on who made an icon (and we all know that's what some people do, unfortunately). Not every icon that makers make is going to be good (elite or otherwise) so it doesn't make sense that the same elite makers win every time. It kinda makes me wish that some of them had closed submissions/voting. Though I guess it does make me appreciate it more when I do win because I'm not one that always gets the votes. But yeah, I like variety.

[everythingshiny]

yeah i like variety, i think that the more people in the comm, the more varied the results are. but then i do feel bad when someone just doesn't seem to ever place. i like closed voting, but i prefer open posts (obviously) i dunno, i just like being able to look at them straight away.

[digitaldesigner]

Yeah, I agree. I like elite comms well enough, but I think some of them are too elite, which really limits the number that can get in (and thus who can really place in challenges). Yeah, I do, too, but at the same time I like how some of them don't give up and keep trying. :) I actually do prefer the open posts. I like being able to get feedback on my icons right away instead of having to wait. I just think that sometimes not knowing who made something would be a good thing in terms of voting. Oh well, can't have it all, I guess.

[everythingshiny]

yeah i dunno how i feel, its really all opinon/your taste based and it makes it hard when people are outside the box.

not knowing is better for voting, but so far i haven't noticed it influencing iconthat so i'm crossing my fingers!

[digitaldesigner]

It's a hard thing, really.

Yeah, I haven't noticed it at fridayfive, either. Let's hope it stays that way for both of them!

[everythingshiny]

i really like comms who make people pick the best of the batch, so you are effectively competing against yourself

[digitaldesigner]

Those are awesome, for sure! :D